The cedar siding out on my side of Harbor Springs always smells like wet bark and pine needles when the lake wind picks up after midnight, a damp, heavy smell that gets right into the drywall and stays there. I was dead tired after closing down the register at the hardware store and driving forty minutes back up the state road in a freezing drizzle that kept icing over the wipers. My joints ached, especially my left thumb where I jammed it in the lumber rack three Tuesdays ago.
I just wanted to drop my canvas tote on the oilcloth kitchen table and sit down with a cup of instant chicory.
I reached for the brass deadbolt with numb fingers, sliding my key into the vertical slot like I had done ten thousand times since Vance passed away four winters ago. It wouldn’t turn. The key hit something hard and flat inside the brass cylinder, stopping dead a quarter-inch short of the pins. I jiggled it, thinking the moisture had frozen up inside the mechanism because the temperature had dropped twenty degrees since noon. I pulled the key back out, squinted against the weak yellow beam of the porch light, and saw a pale sliver of splintered wood wedged flush into the brass throat. Someone had shoved a toothpick right into the keyhole and snapped it off clean at the faceplate.
I had no idea how to get it out. My hands were shaking from the cold and the sheer irritation of the long shift, and I stood there on the damp cedar planks for five minutes trying to dig the wood out with the tip of a sewing needle I found in my glove box.
It didn’t budge. The wood had swollen up tight against the brass pins.
I had to walk three houses down through the wet weeds to get Vince. He was watching the late news in his socks with a bottle of club soda on the end table. Vince didn’t say much. He just grabbed his toolbox from the back porch, walked back down the gravel with me in the dark, and went to work on my front door with a pair of needle-nose pliers and a micro-file. It took him twenty minutes of swearing under his breath to fish out the little wedge of birch.
“Kids from the highway,” Vince muttered, wiping his grease-stained thumb across his knee. “Or some punk messing around. Spray a little graphite in there tomorrow.”
I thought that was the end of it. But the exact same thing happened the very next evening at 8:15 when I came home from picking up a spool of copper wire at the supply depot.
The key hit wood again. Another broken toothpick jammed deep into the brass wards, right down to the shoulder.
That was when Vince suggested setting up a hidden camera. He didn’t ask me twice. He just took down the small battery-powered trail camera he used to watch deer on his property out past the county line, climbed up on an overturned plastic milk crate, and discreetly mounted it behind the peeling gray paint of the front gutter. He aimed it down at an angle that covered the top step, the welcome mat, and the brass knob, entirely hidden from anyone standing on the porch.
The next day, when it happened again while I was at the dentist’s office getting a crown checked, I didn’t even call Vince. I just sat at my small laminate kitchen table, pulled the little black SD card straight out of the plastic housing he handed me, and slipped it into the side slot of my old laptop.
The screen flickered twice, the fan whined, and the video player opened with a sharp, digital pop.
I watched the footage and was stunned to see my own sister-in-law, Brenda, step into the frame at 2:14 in the afternoon. She wasn’t wearing a heavy coat. She just had on her light blue fleece vest and those expensive leather driving gloves I had bought her for her birthday two years ago. She walked right up to the door with an easy, practiced stride, pulled a wooden toothpick out of the pocket of her vest with her right hand, and shoved it deep into the keyhole with a quick, practiced jab of her thumb. She didn’t look around. She didn’t rush. She just did it and turned right back down the steps without a second thought.
I stared at the little moving rectangle on my screen until the laptop battery warning flashed red in the corner. My chest felt tight, like someone had wrapped baling wire around my ribs and started pulling the ends together with pliers. Brenda had keys to my house. She had a full set on a brass ring that she’d kept ever since Vance’s funeral, supposedly so she could water the ferns when I worked a double shift. If she wanted inside, she didn’t need to jam the lock. But she wasn’t trying to get in. She was trying to keep me out, or make me think the neighborhood kids were turning feral, or drive me crazy enough to pack up and move back into town near her.
The quiet in the kitchen was heavier than the damp cedar smell, heavier than the cold coming off the lake through the single-pane windows. I didn’t call the police. I didn’t drive over to her place on Maple Street to bang on her aluminum screen door until she came out in her slippers. I just took the small brass ring out of the kitchen drawer, laid all four of her spare keys in a neat little row on the oilcloth table, and waited for Saturday morning when she usually dropped by to borrow my garden shears.
When her old Buick rolled into the gravel driveway at 10:00 sharp, I didn’t turn on the porch light. I just unlocked the front door myself, pulled it open three inches before she even reached the top step, and left the brass keys sitting right there in the middle of the mat where the camera could see them.
Brenda stopped with her hand half-raised, her face going stiff as she looked down at the metal. She didn’t look surprised. She just looked caught, like a deer staring into high beams before the impact.
“You missed a spot on the camera,” I said.
She didn’t try to lie. She didn’t even drop her jaw or pretend she didn’t know what I meant. She just lowered her hand slowly into the pocket of her fleece vest, her fingers curling around something small and wooden, and stared at me with those cold, hard eyes she must have inherited from our grandmother.
“You were working too much anyway,” she whispered.
That was all she said. She turned around on the top step, walked back down to her Buick without another word, and drove away down the gravel road while I stood in the doorway watching her tail lights disappear into the pines.